No matter what I do, I can't seem to get my hanging indents to actually line up
correctly in a bulleted entry. They are either to the right or left of the
first line in the bulleted entry. Does any one actually have a paragraph
setting that I can apply to my style to fix this? Or, is there a good
informational source out there about this?

It isn't as easy as taking someone else's style as it may have completely
different settings (e.g. indentation) than you want. It SHOULD be fairly
straitforward to setup a hanging indent. Is the indent not working in your
output or your source. Are you applying a style? What is your output type? Are
you using an image for a bullet? More detail is required in order to get to the
bottom of this.